You are here: Home > United States Coins > Nickels

Rare & Collectible U.S. Nickels

We’re pleased to offer rare and collectible U.S. nickels – several from the pre-WWII era – to add to your collection. Each coin has been independently graded by either the NGC or PCGS for transparency and authenticity, and several coins come in a protective plastic case for storage. Choose from Jefferson, Liberty, Shield and Buffalo nickels from several different eras. They make excellent gifts for history buffs and are great conversation pieces. Browse this selection of U.S. nickels for collecting and don’t hesitate to contact us with questions or concerns. Remember that every domestic order ships free!

Sort By:
Page of 2
1875 US Shield Nickel Proof 5C - NGC PF65 Cameo 1881 US Shield Nickel Proof 5C - NGC PF66 Cameo 1912-S US Liberty Head Nickel 5C - PCGS F12
1912-S US Liberty Head Nickel 5C - PCGS F12
Our Price: $180.00
1 in stock!
1913 US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - Type 1 - NGC MS66 - CAC Verified 1913 US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - Type 1 - NGC MS67 CAC Verified 1913-S US Buffalo Nickel 5C - Type One - NGC MS66
1923-S US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - NGC VF30 1929 US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - ICG MS66 1931-S US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - PCGS MS65
1923-S US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - NGC VF30
Our Price: $90.00
1 in stock!
1929 US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - ICG MS66
Our Price: $225.00
1 in stock!
1931-S US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - PCGS MS65
Our Price: $245.00
1 in stock!
1934 US Buffalo Nickel 5C - PCGS MS66 1935 US Buffalo Nickel 5C - PCGS MS67 - CAC 1935-D US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - PCGS MS65
1934 US Buffalo Nickel 5C - PCGS MS66
Our Price: $465.00
1 in stock!
1935 US Buffalo Nickel 5C - PCGS MS67 - CAC
Our Price: $1,125.00
1 in stock!
1935-D US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - PCGS MS65
Our Price: $280.00
1 in stock!
1937-D US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - 3 Legs - NGC AU55 1937-D US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - 3 Legs - NGC XF45 1937-D US Buffalo Head Nickel 5C - 3 Legs - PCGS AU53